Sir Winston Churchill and his Controversial Ten '' wrong'' commandments! @

 Sir Winston Churchill, twice Prime Minister of Britain, occupies a towering yet deeply polarising place in world history. While hailed for his wartime leadership and stirring oratory, he is equally remembered for his arrogance, imperial fanaticism, racial prejudices and his cold disregard for human suffering. His open contempt for Indian nationalism—especially Gandhi, whom he derided as a “half-naked fakir”—symbolised his belief that the British Empire had a sacred mandate to rule.

Two times war time PM Winston churchill
Source: Flicker.com  Public Domain en.wikipedia.org/

 Large sections of British society, particularly the working class, disliked his elitism, and modern historians increasingly highlight the darker, authoritarian edges of his personality. People who are actually familiar with Churchill, completely hate his guts bordering on snobbery and insolence.But in a political and war career spanning some 70 years, he had more than a few moments of controversy  that carry a blot on him..

Churchill's ten ''wrong'' commandments:

1. Preserve British imperial supremacy: Churchill believed the British Empire was the backbone of global civilisation and must be preserved at any cost. Colonies existed to enrich Britain, and the very idea of letting them go was, to him, dangerous and unthinkable.

2. Uphold white supremacy: He championed eugenics, calling for the sterilisation of the “feeble-minded,” and repeatedly expressed racist views about Africans, Indians, Jews, and Indigenous peoples. His remark “I hate Indians” is widely cited as evidence of his deep prejudices.

3. Protect the purity of “Britishness”: Churchill saw the British as inherently superior and born to govern. In his eyes, no continental European or colonised population matched Britain’s cultural or administrative excellence.

1929 Churchill visiting Chaley Choplin
in Hollywood  Author:T.Garrett Public Domain
 commons.wikimedia.org

4. Block India’s freedom: India’s vast natural resources, he believed, were essential for Britain’s economic strength. He obstructed every major constitutional reform and treated Indian leaders with disdain.So,the idea of Home land for the Indians be on the back burner 

Churchill's grave  St.Martin Church Bladon
author :Dennis Lloyd  CC BY -SA 3.0
commons.wikimedia.org

5. Divide to rule: Churchill supported strategies that sharpened Hindu-Muslim divisions, believing communal discord would keep India weak and prolong British power. Allow the Muslim and Hindu communities in the Indian subcontinent to strangle each others' neck. 

Winston Churchill  Author:Charles Alston
Source:US archive and record Administration
commons.wikimedia.org

6. Sanction chemical weapons: In the Middle East and Afghanistan, he supported using poison gas against rebellious tribes, dismissing humanitarian concerns. In 1919, Churchill ordered  to use  poison gas against the helpless waring Kurds who tried hard to protect  their lands from the British India Army


7. Show no compassion in crises: During the Bengal famine of 1943, Churchill refused relief, diverted food shipments to Europe, and blamed the victims. Millions perished due to this callous inaction.When honest British officials contacted Churchill for help,  he scribbled a note in the file: Has Gandhi not died yet? When Lord Wavell succeeded Linlithgow as Viceroy, he was appalled at how little had been done to provide famine relief and prevent public outrage over Churchill's inaction.

 8. Crush Irish aspirations: As Secretary of State for War, he authorised the notorious “Black and Tans,” whose brutality during the Irish War of Independence intensified the conflict.

9. Accept corporate influence: Churchill received large payments from private companies whose interests he defended in Parliament, normalising political lobbying. The media and the public were critical of the role of the "Black and Tans and Churchill's audacity in the matter of homeland for the Irish

Churchill caricature author JJ
at English wikipedia
CC AS- 3.0  commons.wikimedia.org

10. Retaliate without restraint: His endorsement of devastating bombings, including the destruction of Dresden in 1945, reflected a belief that punitive warfare was justified. In the wake of this cruel bombing  countless  innocent civilians—estimated at somewhere between 35,000 and 135,000–were dead. Though American forces were involved, the initiative was taken by Churchill.

These actions reveal a leader far more complex—and far more troubling—than the heroic image often celebrated.  The man who was voted as the most famous English man in the recent past is, paradoxically, the most sinned British subject ever walked on the earth. Based on  https://navrangindia.blogspot.com/2018/12/sir-winston-churchills-ten-wrong.html

https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-29701767



ooo

K. N. Jayaraman Ph. D (1977) Univ. of Washington, Seattle. Retd Earth Scientist.  Vocational Interest: Indian Colonial history, architecture of heritagestructures,colonial buildings,temples,etc.  (Author: navrangindia.blogspot.com )